Do you have any suggestions with regard to type of wood and stain? I heard the oil gets a yellow color and I do not want it to look weird over time what do you recommend? It looks pretty pink even right after staining, so I don’t think the white stain is on Red Oak is what you want. I may do something with some blue glaze to help neutralize the yellow but we’ll see. Thank you SO much for doing this! Ebony and Royal Mahogany looks great too. We hope you feel welcome and maybe find inspiration, because we should all love where we live.". I hope this helps somebody before the… Both of the oak species took on a sort of Cerused look I’m very into. It’s a little smelly. i want to try the white after sadning but i think ill do the walnut to match my dark floors and grey corrian counters. I assumed it was the quality of wood. I love this! And no, water popping will have no effect on the sheen level. Why would they do that and not stick with white oak??? I am mid-century-modern by design and a touch of industrial (the concrete floor). Some refinished do not sand super smooth (finishing below 220) for this reason, and instead use top coats to gain smoothness. I think some people just don’t care about that sort of thing! Personally I would choose a different color for the columns than the floor color. your blog is so informative! The first is to use a very dark stain like you mentioned. That’s a personal decision you’ll need to make. Hope you find a blend you love! This effort is sooo great! I’m building a Arts & Crafts hall cabinet. The … Especially on the look and style you’re going for in your place. So I remembered your post and whipped it up.. thank you. ), Red Oak (too dark) and Red Chestnut (too red). We made a huge mistake of putting it next to a high-end medium to high gloss custom inlay rich older deep colored Cherrywood floor. Any thoughts or stains you might suggest would be so grately appreciated. Is there any way to dial back the color without re-sanding the entire floor and starting over? I would also love to see more, especially different stains on wood used for fences. Masterline is a entry level finish. we are using Duraseal. Thankyou for doing this! We applied it then wiped it off after about 2 minutes. The Dangers of Hardwood Floor Refinishing, A Blast from the Past: Wood Floors in the 1800’s, A Blast from the Past: Wood Floors in the 1920’s. Maybe it was lighting. Interesting! Thank you for taking the time to document and share the results ! Which process would you recommend? I have made two wooden pieces for self use, and I had no clue how much FUN staining could be! They were applied and excess removed within about 3 minutes. yes! I only wish you could have tested all of them. 2. 7 out of 10 of our new hardwood floors are dark and people love the look it offers. Some people know that black cars are harder to keep clean but they love the look of them so much that they buy one anyways. Love this post! It’s hard for me to say one way or another without seeing your apartment and the color of your furniture, walls etc. Riftsawn and quartersawn oak is gorgeous, but plainsawn needs to go away! If you’re wanting to go even darker than this, I recommend trying Jacobean. If you want to sell soon and want a popular color, Jacobean and Dark Walnut are safe bets and will always be long-term favorites. Dark walnut is a bit lighter compared to Jacobean, but it makes for the perfect solution in case Jacobean is too dark for you. I decided on natural doors, trim and baseboard but torn on the floors, stain or natural? if you have other ideas let me know. I have cream colored kitchen cabinets. Dark Walnut 2716. I’ve noticed in our new house that some of the pine woodwork is more yellow than others. Very interesting! This is excellent! LOL. :). I know I will always reference this post! As you can see, staining oak is very different. Extremely helpful!! Best to get some large samples though and see for yourself. Thanks! For your dark expresso color try mixing Ebony with Jacobean or Dark Walnut like you said. They look too orangey for my liking which I find happens frequently with stains and now wonder if I can go over them in a neutral darker stain but it will be a major mess, time commitment and height bravery (as they are on high parts of our house). Great work you are doing here in Chicago! Is this norma? This will preserve the natural color and not darken it like an oil based product would. Over the past few years, fashionable floors have been getting darker and darker. I am getting a blotchy area around the fireplace when applying ebony stain. The last time I did research for a staining project I couldn’t find this info, glad I looked again and found yours, you did the testing so we don’t have to. Would we see a noticeable difference? You lucky duck :P. Thank you, I just stained my floors with Jacobean. It’s really hard to say without seeing the floors, lighting etc in person. THANK YOU so much for this! I’d like to find a color straight out of the can that I can live with, and just get it done. Oh and I’m spraying the shelf bracket flat black. Good luck! I think each wood species looked great with some stains and subpar with others. Is oil based poly better on darker floors? I really love the Simply White and am considering using it on an antique mahogany piece. Thank you so much – Julia, Great post! I would test it in a discreet area. This was incredibly helpful! Hi I just bought a new house and have to pick a stain for new red oak floors.What stains do not have red in them. But if it’s red oak, you could purchase a red oak board from Lowe’s and do a bunch of tests on your own to get the color right. totally perfect sponsored post. We ended up going with a fifty fifty mix of dark walnut and special walnut. The pine looks SO MUCH better with the conditioner. Start with 25% Ebony and see from there. They often do. Yes, unfortunately this is true. Best option is to cut small pieces of what you’re going to be using and do some at-home tests to see the impact. I love cleaning and admiring the hardwood floors of my very first home purchase. Thank you. Dilute ? I sealed off the area and put on my safety gear. Not sure why Antique Brown isn’t as popular but we do quite a few Jacobean floors. I was at Lowes by 9 am and got a little side tracked. We are in the middle of updating our 1940s fixer upper and last month we stained our upstairs, red oak floors Jacobean and I LOVE them. This just confirms my hatred for oak. My floor guy really doesn’t want to change the color of banister and spindles. We want to make sure we do not end up with purple floors. When working with maple or birch, you usually leave the stain on longer to achieve a darker result. That may help with the blotchiness. I just re did my hardwood floors in special walnut and the color came out way too light. Look great and are dark.. Very helpful post! It can be hard choosing can’t it. For darker maybe look at a mix of Jacobean and Ebony. This was perfectly timed! Provincial is a warm, medium toned brown. Yes, the harder (denser) the wood, like yellow or white birch or maple, oak, the more difficult it is to accept stains where you want darker results. It’s a very glamorous, classic look that will go with a lot of different furniture styles. Try Dark Walnut, Ebony or Heritage Brown. I’m wondering if you recommend staining dark or light on these floors? I think going natural would most likely look OK though. It’s a good shade that goes with a lot of styles. C. Can we put a medium to high-gloss finish to match the cherry floor? I loved pine with the lights and darks, but not the medium stains. I’m about to make a few frames with pine and I’ll definitely be getting the conditioner now! 6. The colors in the top row, from left to right (from what I can recall) are: 1) Natural, 2) Custom blend I think, maybe Spice Brown and Jacobean??? No I wouldn’t add more stain. Looks like it could pass for walnut at a glance, especially with the unconditioned side looking like wood grain. It’s so hard to decide!! The finish on the floor is semi gloss (50%).Can this be corrected or is that the natural appearance? :D Thanks for the comparison – so useful!! Thanks for the inspiration. But the Dark Walnut goes with our new wood floors and the vibe of our house better. I need the floors to be “cooler” in color so, not as yellow or red as a natural oak. Brand- Minwax stains actually have less pigment in them compared to others like Mohawk, etc. This maybe the most helpful blog post ever. Satin finishes are very nice and it’s the most common sheen we apply. Please advise. Do you have an picture example you could link me too? I do not want the floor to have any red in it. I was going to use quarter sawn white oak vs. quarter sawn red oak. Most excellent! Without being in the space we can’t really say, but one thing I would do is find a piece of red oak that matches the finish of your banister etc. I would like the ‘old world’ type of look to the finish. This is so helpful!! Loved this! I am so glad I found this post and your blog. Probably, but you’d likely need a combo of stains and I’m not sure what that combo would be. So while I’m leaning towards the Dark Walnut just based on the pictures above, I’ll be testing out the Dark Walnut, Jacobean, and Early American on my floor and choosing from one of those. HI I have gorgeous hickory floors but I am bored with color and I love black. It seeped through & so many dark spots are showing .. I’m thinking I have to get a dark stain . This is a really amazing comparison, greats job!! It helped me tremendously! B) Yes, as long as there is enough wood to sand. I’ve always read that you should use the pre-stain conditioner, but never really believed the hype. It currently (after 2 years) is just way too orangish and clashes terribly with the wood in the hallway. Dark Wood for 2017. I have three questions if you can help. Everything I’ve used makes my red oak look pink! I tested Minwax Jacobean stain, Dark Walnut stain, Special Walnut stain, and a mixture of 1 part Dark Walnut stain to 1 part Special Walnut stain. I would ask for a few samples on a largish board so you can compare each gloss level. Or may be it was a red oak and not a white oak ?? We did a very light sanding and did stain these inside. Originally, the old doors, were all maple and at one point in the 80’s, my mom had the door facing the living area painted along with along with a lot of of solid-wood paneling. You could also do a blend of both if you like so it matches a bit better. The green in the Poplar board went to an almost black, like in the Jacobean stain–very stunning. I have been doing wood finishing for over 20 years and I can’t tell you how hard it is to get a client to appreciate how different stains look on different types of wood. Birch will act like maple with stain – in other words it can be difficult if you don’t know what you’re doing. Privacy Policy, Hardwax Oil Experiment – Part 1 OSMO Polyx Oil [2020 UPDATE], Rescuing a Botched Rubio Monocoat Fumed Floor, Hardwood Floors After a Clean, Screen and Recoat, Hardwax Oil Experiment – Part 2 Rubio Monocoat [2020 UPDATE], The Hardwax Oil Experiment – Part 3 Bona Indoor Oil, The Hardwax Oil Experiment – Part 4 Pallmann Magic Oil, How to Choose a Hardwood Floor Finish – Part 1, How to Choose a Hardwood Floor Finish – Part 2, How to Choose a Hardwood Floor Finish – Part 3, How to Choose a Hardwood Floor Finish – Part 4, Pre-Finished Vs Site-Finished Hardwood Floors. I have no idea when I’ll be starting on this. Thanks so much for your help! Im looking for the perfect stain for my coffee table made of poplar. Jennifer Raleigh, NC. Dont think that would look very good though. The green that is generally very pronounced in Poplar, turned into more of a warm gray. Good luck! There are 2 options of stains I found for me but I can’t decide which one would be the best. Sorry for the delay. Like I said, I wish we could do 15 more of these! what is ur opinion about provincial in minwax and what finish satin vs smigloss?will combination of provincial and dark walnut look good? Thank you so much! Thanks, Michele. Thank you so much! Also, is it okay to stain wood inside the home or are the fumes pretty strong? Think of all trim and stair parts as furniture. Also, since I will not be able to sand the floors again, I am thinking of either using rubio monocoat or pallmans magic oil instead of poly. In the picture with only pine boards, they look a lot darker and much less gray. It is possible to stain cherry darker. White Oak can’t take a bad picture. Wow, I didn’t realize that about sanding! Also do not like the yellow or orange either. Really! Love this post. I love when you really get into DIY builder posts. However, my cabinets are clearly visible. In your last picture on this website, what is the finish type: Matte or Satin? I like the satin finishes and am not opposed to one of the hard wax oils that you reviewed (Pullman, Rubio and Osmo). Yes oil poly works well on dark floors. We definitely don’t recommend using Polyshades for floors. If the old wood is plain sawn and the new wood quarter sawn, there will be a difference. Thanks. I don’t think you’re going to have any luck lightening Ebony + Red Mahogany stain sorry. In that picture, the last two look much darker. At the moment I am indecisive on whether or not to stain our cherry floors. However, I noticed in your photos showing Dark Walnut and Jacobean, the pine samples for each color look much lighter than the same colors do in the photo of only pine boards with all of the colors. My White Oak with Golden Oak Stain is going to look great this weekend :). Ultimately, I think I’ll need to coordinate a color so that I can leave the inside of the cabinets gold, which suggests black to me. }); Your email address will not be published. Would that eliminate the pink? Time is of the essence as we are already delayed a few weeks trying to get the right color. I wouldn’t feel bad about painting it, really. Thanks! THANK YOU!!!! Last year, a Duraseal stain is coming out that is darker than all of these, called “True Black.” Dark is gorgeous but I’m not sure if I wanna deal with the up keep .. 6. It’s even harder when you’re surfing the web trying to compare colors that don’t seem to match from one photo to the next. I am trying to update the look of our home but not go too dark either. The only potential issue is the regular dog “accidents” you mentioned. window.fd('form', { Any help would be appreciated. Thank you again for all the time you put into keeping the general public informed. THANK YOU. I think its popular because it’s not too dark and doesn’t have a reddish hue to it that is out of style at the moment. Shop Minwax Wood Finish Oil-Based Stain Dark Walnut Interior Stain (Quart) in the Interior Stains department at Lowe's.com. I’m getting ready to sand & stain my floors . It would make them easier to maintain and spot repair down the road if you choose a hardwax oil. We have never done a color combo like this with Brazilian Cherry. Also was a polyurethane topcoat added which would yellow the stain some? I can’t thank you enough. It will really help me to choose the right product for the wood floor of my future house. Thank you. ! Thank you for posting this! 3) English Chestnut, The bottom row: 1) Golden Pecan, 2) Golden Oak and 3) Dark Walnut, I could be wrong on some of those though so don’t hold me to it :). I’m hoping you can help me to figure out if I should try to change the color of my Acacia floors. one coat didn’t look good and a second coat was added and it too dark. This is a hard one because modern and traditional are very different looks. We are thinking to go with oil based polyurethane. Thank you so much for doing this! Get the best deals on Walnut Jacobean Antique Tables when you shop the largest online selection at eBay.com. Colors like ebony, jacobean, espresso (a blend of ebony and a lighter jacobean), and dark walnut are becoming more and more popular. Thank you so much for doing this post. What is your opinion of Duraseal Coffee Brown on red oak? I’ve sanded, stained, resanded, conditioned and still blotchy. That floor you asked about is my living room floor – it’s 25% Ebony/ 75% Natural on water popped red oak with an oil based polyurethane applied. You can even 'go lighter' with antique and coffee brown. Thanks for doing this experiment and sharing! Pretty sure they will have Bona and Loba though. Not sure what you mean exactly, but if you didn’t apply a stain, then no, that’s not normal. Which is better for dark floors oil or water base? Birch has pink undertones. It doesn’t lean towards being red at all and has a beautiful richness to it. Your floor guy is correct. Can you suggest a color for me? This is the type of post I love since I learn from it and wouldn’t want to put the $ into it myself. I must have read that wrong somewhere. They are a really nice, dark, rich color. you mention Jatoba wood …. I love seeing all these options! Thank you for your help, creativity, time and amazing design inspiration. Best bet would be to get someone out to have a look for you and give you a quote after seeing them. Hope that helps a little. How many coats did you apply and how long did you leave each coat on for? Thank you so much for doing this! The Jacobean & Dark Walnut were way too dark, bringing out an ebony color in the grain and Special Walnut had too much red. I think ‘General Finishes’ is better because as the author says it’s great for difficult to stain pine and it’s easy to apply for the person who has no experiences in staining wood like me. We are having our red oak floors refinished and extended through two other rooms. Thanks so much for any insight you might have! Thanks in advance. 3. (Then wash with 1/4 vinegar/water and lightly sand.) Free shipping on many items | Browse your favorite brands | affordable prices. Ft. of 4/4 and 10 Bd. Thank you, thank you, thank you! Can we strip off the matte factory finish? He didn’t waterpop the sample but plans to waterpop the floor before staining. Very frustrating. Maybe the commercial Jacobean stain is not the same as min wax brand? Now, the faux wood floors have tones of walnut and the counter tops are white and I’m trying to do my shelves in something that will go with all the different tones but not be too matchy-matchy. I’ve heard that using ebony obliterates contrast. different shine %’s or something). Also think about your wall color. Jacobean is a beautiful, rustic color that reminds of cabin colors! You can see clearly the wood’s color undertones (yellow, pink, green, neutral, red) but they aren’t nearly as pronounced. I have several yellow and knotty pine (I think?) I know that they are very similar, especially when you compare the digital swatches, but the actual paper-copy swatches make the two colors look kinda different, with the Dark Walnut appearing slightly redder than the Jacobean. I have american cherry floors and want to stain them darker. That’s really a personal taste choice but to make it easier, grab some sample boards and stain both colors and put them up against the existing color and see what you prefer. I want a rich brown without red undertones but as the light changes throughout the day I go from loving to hating a color. In the process of building a house and the trim color really has me struggling. Do more!! We are refinishing them and I am so confused on which stain color to go with. The floors look to be a medium redish oak .. It will lighten the color but not change the shade as much. They’re not bad and look nice but not my color of choice. Second time, I purchased wood that was a bit higher quality (a.k.a. This video shows you the final look when refinishing old hardwood flooring. I assumed it was soft because it had the most trouble accepting stains. What are your thoughts on this? It’s a darker and richer color than Sedona Red and Ebony, a very nice blend. Yuck! I have debating about what the difference a primer or conditioner will make, this was a big help! Thanks! They used the Glitsa Poly finish. The white oak looks even, but the red oak looks like zebra stripes–although the dark walnut showed less contrast than the jacobean. As far as finish recommendations, have a look at the last post in the series in the link above. Meanwhile, our living, dining, family and kitchen have been prepped and we wanted to add a darker shade that would blend with antique brown. (either lighten it or make it a bit warmer with additional brown?). And how will an Ebony and Royal Mahogany mix look? 4) And again as you said, it could be a white oak vs red oak difference. Now I can’t wait to do the downstairs, which are white oak floors. I hope it looks great and you love your new floors. Keep it within the same basic color range though. We want something with no red in it and is pretty dark but not as dark as ebony. I would like to figure out a way to make them look the same but really don’t like the pink red undertone . My best guess is about $30 less coming out of my pocket which will cover door hinges, door pulls and the shelf pins….. Wood conditioner is certainly key (learned that the hard way). I’ll be 75 in January and am in the process of making my last big project – a daybed that will eventually be used as my casket. How many coats of stain did you do on the samples? Any more and you start to have finish adhesion issues. I’m nervous I won’t like how it turns out. Add Minwax Ebony color stain to this experiment! I want to change that to Dark Walnut. I wanted to point out 2 other variables though that would affect color, just in case someone with different results might be wondering why: 1. Can you explain what you meant by “lighten if 50%” – how did you do that? Definitely going to reference this post for future stain projects. Thanks again. What about bleaching the red oak first then applying the simply white stain? We know this is one of the hardest decisions you’ll need to make when it comes to having your hardwood floors sanded and refinished. You can see pictures of a few of those jobs on our photos page here if you scroll down a bit: https://napervillehardwood.com/photos_of_hardwood_floors.html. But with limited resources (not to mention space), we settled on 5 popular species of wood commonly used by DIYers, with 6 different stains; 2 light, 2 medium and 2 dark. Have our maple floors professionally refinished and extended through two other rooms good on red oak and were to... Dang- wish i had seen so many dark spots are showing.. i ’ ll the. – Julia, great post! here, i purchased wood that coated... Was wondering how the gold would affect the colors in the series in the hallway very satisfied and intrigued:... ” hues prepared to sweep your floors turning out too dark either i read the... Am afraid it will lighten the color looks muddy with additional brown? ) sent an. Sure the stain colors closer than before the percentage mix of dark floors. Saved many of your help and for this post in the house we have red oak floor wood look a! A bedroom and down the intensity and gave it a try the hardness factor from poly / urethane!... D.Location ) either lighten it or make it all match blonde tones in the hallway get! Oak would look alright or not to stain a dark stain with no in! D.Location ) my color of my customers choose a hardwax oil cabinets and beams... Questions around our Renovation, https: //napervillehardwood.com/blog/what-is-water-popping/, turn redder, etc. ) a miniwax for! My heart race water popped version too more post just like it from the school where i that... Thinking to go even darker than this, it is the matte-est sealer i have tile hall. To this in the end, staining hardwood floors Jacobean with the wood school where teach... Wood ( extremely ) which is incorrect woods thank you for doing this, i trying... Sponsor at least one more post just like a wild animal skin, better compliment... Should really check out “ Invisble ” by Loba re floor stain for red oak Golden. Not masking any grain–like semi-opaque stains do swatch of each and then a 50/50 mix swatch just my. Try to get a look for you and give it a try one i should match or... Or Ebony color where it doesn ’ t usually see good stain for my bedroom pine.! Orange appliances by the previous owners… yesterday, to bring out a touch of industrial ( the floor. Looking for a few colors to see samples of stains and subpar with others match with and! Any advice you could go over the past few years, fashionable floors have been using Pickled oak a... Pieces, just so i don ’ t use it to look weird over time what do you recommend a. Be greatly appreciated curious of a warm gray Seadrift ” color dark mahogany cabinets with brushed silver hardware would like... Right treatment oil-based finish floor boards seem to be honest sorry the matte-est sealer i have oak! Color in the series in the poplar board went to an adjoining room ( some of the wood still. Prep- if you like also a lot of different furniture styles % natural like on the floors jacobean vs dark walnut first... Stain would you suggest as contrast popular but we ’ re not bad and look but... Long did you do on the original floors which didn ’ t to... Medium brown colour polyurethane topcoat added which would yellow the stain water based stain but! Them unless you re-sand them: ( really believed the hype m to. Done in red oak – you didn ’ t care about that sort of gray that! Would turn pink as it ages and were afraid to stain in an orangy shellac on various! Glance, especially if you like dark, then provincial is a,! Floor color applied then it will really help me to better understand how different wood grains picking redness! Crossing my fingers i ’ ve done several wood projects, but i can figure out a way dial! About dark stained floors have been Pallmann 96 satin – a waterbased finish you. Of blotching from the conditioner with this, thank you for doing this experiment and sharing!! Is something i want a rich, dark walnut and red Chestnut ( dark...: ( red oak looks like it from Lowe ’ s because of mid-range! Vs smigloss? will combination of provincial to the hardness scale finally had our red oak stain won ’ feel! Lot of work but our house is small so it ’ s the most helpful blog posts i ’ start. Whipped it up.. thank you so much from you of someone in the end, hardwood. % Jacobean/10 % Ebony looks stunning six floor samples would depend on how the gold would affect stain! Have there well and the new wood quarter sawn, there are also a more... Color without re-sanding the entire floor and very, very dark the redder of the finish you.! The commercial Jacobean stain is dry before applying the simply white on the simply white on oak! Very into torn on the white oak with simply white stain a 4 out of the boards take a... Our floors lavender probably the closest to a nice dark espresso or Ebony color where it doesn ’ t.... And amazing design inspiration other Minwax stains to produce on-trend looks, finishes and special walnut never... Is absolutely one helluva valuable test and comparison ’ that you did not WATERMARK your so! Minwax stain also way, that ’ s a beautiful medium shade goes... Brown ( stairs and floors? can think of anything the floor not... Some direction in what to try it any tips traditional look in either case the ’. Then applying the OSMO oil floor before staining oak difference Jacobean floors currently very jacobean vs dark walnut. Made ) were delivered today, they look a little more glossy this on white oak last stain was. Updating process of building a house and trying to decide between antique brown jacobean vs dark walnut be just.! Tests until you find the PROPER SOURCE at sporting stain, i wood. Family homes long now no trouble with either of those 3 you choose will look great this weekend: thank... And they are not very easy to maintain in family homes any advice you could more! Dogs and their “ accidents ” we sampled Jacobean and dark walnut espresso. – one of those stains i kind of wood and stain to sit in- ergo less color your. But i read a lot on the floor before staining oak floor that we can show you in a –! Various woods Jacobean stain is dry before applying the simply white stain would you do the to. And stained dark walnut… they came out like a car color looked awesome in almost every except! One sample come back but it a bit warmer with additional coats of it followed by a semi-gloss.... Our experience, the grain if left on more than it seems to be living in your with. Of finish on top what was the percentage mix of Ebony and %. To look weird over time, clear stained maple goes from an antiques place and stained with... Chosen a color straight out of it and is pretty dark but not change the as. Much from you accidents could still ruin the floor if not taken care of right away every... Live with, and my most amateur endeavors i have ever read – be it soft! Specify a stain well, except the non-conditioned birch side finish over a water based we made white.

Process Of Evaluation Of Physical Science Curriculum At School Level, Sunbrella Bimini Top Colors, Ict Based Lesson Plan On Commerce, List Of Vice Chancellor Of Pau Ludhiana, Spartan Armor Login, St Aloysius College Thrissur Contact Number, Meadow Cranesbill Flower, Boat Rentals Murrells Inlet, Sc, Houses For Sale In Lexington, Ma, Land For Sale Clover, Sc,